Before You Rate Performance, Check What You Agreed

“But you’ve always told me my work was okay. Why am I only hearing this now?”
As appraisal season begins, this is a question some supervisors may find difficult to answer. The employee is surprised by the feedback. The supervisor has been unhappy for some time. Yet their earlier conversations never quite addressed the gap.
In my work with reporting officers, I find that the difficulty often lies in balancing care and challenge. Kim Scott’s Radical Candor framework provides a useful lens for understanding these conversations.
Some supervisors care about their staff but avoid challenging them. Conversations are encouraging: “You’re doing well. Thank you for your hard work.” Specific suggestions for improvement remain unspoken. This is what Scott calls Ruinous Empathy. The intention may be to protect the relationship, but the employee loses the opportunity to improve.
This becomes particularly difficult when former peers become reporting officers. The reporting relationship changes, but their conversations remain those of good colleagues. The supervisor lets things slip, even as dissatisfaction grows. Meanwhile, the employee reasonably assumes that everything is fine.
Other supervisors offer little care or challenge. “Okay” becomes the standard response. As long as there are no major mistakes or complaints, work carries on. There is little discussion about what better performance would look like.
At the other extreme, supervisors challenge without care. “Someone at your level should know this.” “Why can’t you use your brain?” Scott calls this Obnoxious Aggression. Such remarks attack the person while providing little clarity about how to improve.
A caring and challenging conversation requires preparation. The supervisor needs to describe specific observations and their impact: “The last two reports contained factual inaccuracies and required correction before we could send them to the client. This delayed submission.”
Then pause.
Ask: “How do you see the situation?”
Listen. Clarify. “Tell me more” can be more useful than immediately offering a solution. Competing demands, unclear priorities or capability gaps may emerge. Understanding these conditions helps both parties identify what needs to change.
Where feedback has been delayed, supervisors also need to acknowledge that: “I should have raised this with you earlier.” They need to distinguish between expectations that already applied and new expectations arising from changes in the work. Employees need a clear opportunity to understand and respond to those changes.
Drawing on Peter Block’s approach to contracting, I believe the conversation should clarify two things: the work itself and the working relationship.
The first includes targets, quality standards, deadlines and deliverables. The second includes how we work together. How will feedback be given? How will concerns be raised? What support can the employee expect? What ownership will the employee take?
We often spend more time discussing the first and leave the second assumed.
There may be disappointment, defensiveness or hurt. Give people space to respond while keeping the conversation focused on understanding, improvement and agreed action. Agree on support and when progress will be reviewed.
Responsibility cuts both ways. Supervisors need the courage to give honest feedback and the commitment to develop their staff. Employees need to take ownership of staying current and building their capability.
Before assigning a rating, ask yourself: Have we clearly agreed what good performance looks like and how we will work together to achieve it?



Comments